Truth vs. Torture

Published on Dissident Voice (first on CODEPINK/Blogand click on BLOG), John Kiriakou and the Torture Report, by Cayman Kai, April 3, 2014.

Although the Senate Intelligence Committee voted on Thursday to declassify a report detailing the CIA’s use of torture that will confirm the 2007 revelations from John Kiriakou, former CIA analyst and case officer, Kiriakou himself is still languishing in prison. Kiriakou still has at least another year left in prison, but as Americans confront the horror contained within the Torture Report, they ought to also call for justice and freedom for the brave whistleblower who warned us about it years ago.  

On December 10, 2007 in an interview with ABC News, Kiriakou discussed his involvement in the capture and questioning of Abu Zubaydah, accused aide of Osama Bin Laden. Kiriakou admitted the CIA’s use of waterboarding on Al-Qaeda suspects, specifically Zubaydah, making him the first U.S. official to do so. If it had not been for Kiriakou, the public would not have known about the use of torture, which has now led to the call for the release of the Torture Report. Kirakou expressed doubts that the information gathered from waterboarding was worth the damage to the United States’ reputation.

On January 23, 2012 Kiriakou was charged with revealing the name of an undercover officer and the role of another officer in classified activities and a year later was sentenced to 30 months in prison. However, the case of Scooter Libby, former advisor to Vice President Dick Cheney, suggests that Kiriakou’s punishment is about more than his revelation of an undercover officer. In October 2005, Libby was charged with revealing the identity of an undercover CIA officer, which had endangered her life. He was also sentenced to 30 months, but President Bush commuted his sentence and Libby simply paid a fine and had two years of supervised release and completed 400 hours of community service. Despite the fact that Libby’s transgression was more serious than what John was accused of, John was the one imprisoned. This fact suggests that perhaps John was forced to complete his full sentence to punish him for his revelation of torture, even though he was not officially charged for it.

Despite the CIA’s claims to the Department of Justice and Congress that their actions helped to obtain valuable information to disrupt terrorist plots and save thousands of lives, the torture report will show that this is false. For example, all useful information from Zubaydah was obtained well before he was waterboarded a grand total of 83 times. “The CIA conflated what was gotten when, which led them to misrepresent the effectiveness of the program,” said an anonymous U.S. official who has seen the report … //

… (full text).

(Cayman is currently an intern at the CODEPINK Washington, DC office. She is a sophomore at Northeastern University in Boston majoring in International Affairs and Political Science. Read other articles by Cayman, or visit Cayman’s website).


The Expandables: How NATO ‘conquered’ Europe, on Russia Today RT, April 4, 2014;

The death of a great American city: why does anyone still live in Detroit? The city’s social contract was shredded long ago and everyone knows time is running out – but some Detroiters have hope – Published on The Guardian, by David Uberti in Detroit, April 3, 2014:

Wrongful death suits have cost Veterans Affairs over $200 million since 9/11 – report, on Russia Today RT, April 3, 2014;

Pyrrhic victory for whistleblowers on Transatlantic Trade Agreement, on Russia Today RT, April 2, 2014: Currently a Research Associate at the INSYTE Group, Dr. Roslyn Fuller has previously lectured at Trinity College and the National University of Ireland. She can be reached at …;

The Ukraine and the beginning of the multipolar world, on Russia Today RT, March 7, 2014: Unbeknownst to the wider world, two enormous trade deals have been in the works for the past several years. Shrouded in secrecy, talks on these deals, which will cover over half of world trade in goods and services and which include such sensitive topics as intellectual property rights, flew under just about everyone’s radar …;

Comments are closed.